Doomstead Anti-Diner

Off the keyboard of RE

Follow us on Twitter @doomstead666
Friend us on Facebook

Godwin

Published on the Doomstead Diner on April 20, 2014

A couple of years ago with my friend Peter and a few other folks I chatted with on my Yahoo Group Reverse Engineering, we put up a Blog and Forum called the Doomstead Diner. The Diner was an evolution from years of time spent managing forums and years of time chronicling the Collapse of Industrial Civilization.

The main reason we created this blog & forum was because of issues I have had over the years with Censorship and Banning on other websites, including in fact the Reverse Engineering group itself, which had issues with Yahoo Bots doing the censoring.

The goal was to allow Free Speech to the MAX, eschewing the typical Banning and Deletions of posting you find on just about all Blogs and Forums. This wasn’t always easy, but for a good 2 years it mostly worked. However, in recent weeks it has succumbed to Godwin’s Law, (the longer a forum goes, the more likely Nazi comparisons are made) among other typical Trolling issues.

Forums are a kind of microcosm of society, which generally no matter how large the website, tend to have a fairly limited number of “regular” posters. It seems to range from about 10-50 people no matter where you go. There are exceptions of course like Zero Hedge, which is SOOOO HUGE 100s of people post every day in the commentary, but that is very atypical.

During its most successful period, the Diner developed a small but tightly knit community of people with similar interests and similar perspectives on the collapse we see occuring around us every day. Initially it was just meant to be a Newz and Discussion blog, but as time went by the realization came that we needed to come together not just in Cyberspace, but IRL as well. IRL is “In Real Life” for those of you not conversant with internet acronyms.

This need to come together IRL finally culminated in the 1st Diner Convocation, which occurred last week down in Texas. It was a time of great celebration amongst those who attended, but it had an unforseen Blowback in Cyberspace on the Diner itself, where all these folks found each other to begin with.  Trolls took control of the Diner commentary, and any semblance of reasonable conversation went to the Great Beyond.

SAMSUNG CSC

On any forum, factions develop and the Diner is no different there. The faction on the Diner which views negatively the efforts to form community and to develop sustainable systems took the opportunity to troll the Diner to death, and this put a cloud over the IRL celebration. The acrimony over perceived and fabricated “injustices” persisted (and still persists) a full week after the Convocation, leading many Diners including myself to be completely disgusted by the conversation taking place on the Diner Forum.

The No Ban/No Censorship policy has its own Blowback, and trying to find a work around to this short of reneging on this policy has consumed my time in the aftermath. I still want to have friendly conversation with my friends, and I still want to bring the message of Collapsing Industrial Civilization out to more people. The toxic environment the Diner Trolls were bent on perpetuating was making both things impossible.

Having spent so much time, energy and money to get this thing rolling, giving up on it is not an option for me. So I am developing still more work-arounds to the Trolling issue, and hopefully the latest changes will clear things up. The solutions won’t make everyone happy, but some good results have already come from this.

First change is that we opened up the WordPress Comments on the Diner Blog, which makes it a whole lot easier for casual readers and newbies to comment on the Diner. Second is that it provided motivation to open up a New Forum on SUN4Living, where Diners can go to post up material specific to developing sustainable communities.

The most important change here is that the Diner needs a place where the folks who are perpetually dissatisfied with the way the Administration of the Diner is done have their own spot to freely air their grievances, without monopolizing the Diner forum itself. Basically an Op-Ed page on Steroids, where Diners can go to complain about the Diner.

To this end, we now have a Doomstead Anti-Diner with it’s own set of Anti-Diner Admins to run it as they see fit. You can access the Anti-Diner from the Diner Forum menu to read the latest in complaints about the Diner. You can view the Anti-Diner as a kind of Doppelganger, the Evil Twin of the Diner.

Hopefully with all these changes, we can return now to discussing the issues of the day WRT the collapse of Industrial Civilization, without devolving into endless bickering over complete nonsense. Granted, this is a fairly complex solution, but at the moment there is sufficient Available Energy to implement it. I look forward to reading the endless series of complaints on the Anti-Diner and may even contribute myself on those pages periodically, assuming the Admins over there grant me posting priviledges.

Your Friendly Neighborhood Diner Admin

RE

5 Responses to Doomstead Anti-Diner

  • enicar666 says:

    Pot meet Kettle. :roll:

    The goal was to allow Free Speech to the MAX, eschewing the typical Banning and Deletions of posting you find on just about all Blogs and Forums. This wasn’t always easy, but for a good 2 years it mostly worked. However, in recent weeks it has succumbed to Godwin’s Law, (the longer a forum goes, the more likely Nazi comparisons are made) among other typical Trolling issues.

    It happens.

  • toktomi says:

    Since I don’t “know” anything, I’ll offer a quick story about a long term situation of the past that has never ceased to amaze me.

    During the earlier years of this century Scott Meredith created one or more Yahoo Discussion Groups. One in particular, Alas Babylon was completely unmoderated and by my evaluation, completely successful for many years. I saw Scott take action against a member only once, and that was only after a fair bit of pleading from other members about a particularly awful little bug.

    Scott eventually gave AB away to one of the members and moved off to http://cattanga.typepad.com/tabby_cat_gamespace/ where he still resides. AB became moderated under the new ownership and went anorexic.

    Perhaps, there is a lesson in there somewhere. Perhaps, not. Good luck.

    ~toktomi~

    PS I read some of your postings over at NBL. I believe that you need to keep in mind that Carolyn Baker and Guy McPherson have revenue streams to maintain and that to challenge their words is to challenge their livelihoods.

    “And now we have the New Age, and all kinds of therapies and therapists and counsellors who’ll take your cash for a book and dvd and a private consultation if you can afford it. It’s just a new priesthood for a new religion, and NTE is a whole new business opportunity for a whole new industry to arise…” (http://collapseofindustrialcivilization.com/2013/09/28/rules-of-the-game-for-our-dystopian-world/)

  • Harry Lerwill says:

    I like the new direction people are going since the convocation, those who attended –and a few who wanted to but could not –are focused on positive steps to mitigate the challenges of climate chaos, energy depletion and fiscal imbalances. Doing, rather than talking, has always been my goal and the main reason I found the Diner in the first place, following a breadcrumb trail of people making positive changes and blogging about it.

    I’m looking forward to the second convention!

  • monsta666 says:

    To me free speech is like any other freedom or right. It is okay to exercise your freedom provided it is does not infringe on the well being of another individual in a negative matter. In the case of free speech this means that a person loses their right to free speech if they commit several instances of hate speech or/and questioning the integrity of another person without sufficient proof. Now when it comes to proof it need be something significant but what people should avoid is countless baseless criticism. If people engage in this behaviour they should forfeit their right to free speech. All freedoms come with certain responsibilities and obligations and people need to bear this in mind when exercising their rights.

  • Harry Lerwill says:

    Excellent points, Tokomi.

    I make a point of not going over to NBL and challenging their viewpoints, there’s no point. We each choose our own reaction to our own mortality – none of us are getting out of here alive. Their reactions to the situation our world is in is understandable, and with different life-experiences I could see myself taking a similar tack. As it is, I fought my way out of crippling childhood poverty and find it hard to not engage in the struggle to make the world a better place.

    Controversy can generate traffic, and Guy is not adverse to doing so. The negative article in the UK guardian doubled his traffic, and he kept about 30% of it. Difference there was it was a reasoned “negative article”, upon which people could agree to disagree, and a significant number who read it still feel that Guy’s research is worth following. I for one read his blog posts, but don’t share his conclusion; he thinks all of humanity will die off, I expect 5% or so to survive. I plan to be part of that 5% or die trying. :)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Daily Rant 7/18/2014
Recent Articles

Muscle Over Mind

Off the keyboard of Jason Heppenstall Follow us on Facebook...

War Zones

From the keyboard of James Howard Kunstler Follow us...

Malaysian Flight 17: Close Encounters of the Stupid Kind

Off the microphone of RE Follow us on Facebook Follow...

A Gazillionaire Looks to the Future: Sees Pitchforks

From the keyboard of Thomas Lewis Follow us on Facebook...

Fashion vs Will to Power III

Off the keyboards of Steve from Virginia and RE Follow...

It Was Putin’s Missile!

Off the keyboard of Pepe Escobar Follow us on Twitter @doomstead666...

The Anti-Empire Report #129

From the Keyboard of William Blum Follow us on Twitter @doomstead666...

This Week in Doom: Appointment at Sentara

Off the keyboard of Surly1 Follow us on Twitter @doomstead666...

Flying: Unsafe at Any Altitude

Off the keyboard of RE Follow us on Twitter @doomstead666...

World Cup Reality Check

Off the microphone of RE Follow us on Twitter @doomstead666...

Collapse Cafe
Recent Podcasts

TSA Follies & Myths of Transportation Security

Off the Microphone of RE Follow us on Twitter @doomstead666...

Fukushima: The Gift that Keeps on Giving

Off the microphone of RE Follow us on Twitter @doomstead666...

Ukraine Nazi Deja Vu

Off the microphone of RE Follow us on Twitter @doomstead666...

The Week That Was
Archives
Off the Grid

Winter Garage Greenhouse

                                                                                                                                                                            ...

That Was The Week That Was in Doom June 23, 2013

From the Keyboard of Surly1 Originally published on...

The Week That Was In Doom, May 26, 2013

From the Keyboard of Surly1 Originally published on...

Boston Marathon Bombing

Off the keyboard of William Hunter Duncan Discuss this...

Twilight of the Standard Model

Off the keyboard of William Hunter Duncan Published...

God and Football

Off the keyboard of William Hunter Duncan Originally...

2013 thus far, America

Well, 2013. Here we are, not yet a month in, and it...

RIP Aaron Swartz

Off the keyboard of William Hunter Duncan Originally...

Doom and the Spiritual Path

Off the keyboard of William Hunter Duncan Published...

Realities, 2013

Off the keyboard of William Hunter Duncan Originally...

Newzhound Joe Storiez

http://www.isd547.com/Elem/extras/images/dogreporter.jpg



20 Things the Poor Really Do Every Day

Billionaire threatens charity donations if Pope continues support for the poor

Why SAC's Steven Cohen Isn't in Jail

Social Darwinism Isn’t Dead

Producers Panic as Ethanol Mandate Loses Support

Deep sea creatures 'will not escape climate change'

Worker aghast at shoddy work on Fukushima radioactive water storage tanks

Losing Aaron

Military drones to get stronger chemical weapons and make their OWN decisions

Brainlike Computers, Learning From Experience

Human evolution, from tree to braid

Most Underreported Stories of 2013

North Dakota’s explosive Bakken oil: The story behind a troubling crude

BP wins first Greenland drilling concession despite chequered record

The War Nerd: Mo cattle and oil, mo problems in South Sudan

Britain: Fiercest storm for 20 years...and it will get WORSE over the weekend

Chickenfuckers are A-okay with the NSA

They Didn’t Give a Flute

Valdosta banker accused of faking suicide to avoid fraud charges

The Decline and Fall of Post War Liberalism and the Rise of the Right

Daunting Calculus for Maine Shrimpers as Entire Season Is Lost

2013 was a good year for climate science, but a mixed bag for climate policy

The heat on 'green' activism

Pictures - U.S. Northeast has first fierce winter storm of 2014

The Madness of the Planets

The Gas Guzzler

Exxon Russia Ambitions Show Oil Trumps Obama-Putin Spats

Syrian Opposition Condemns Russian Oil Deal

China's Ambassador To Britain Says Japan Is Like Lord Voldemort

Great story telling is vital to winning the green debate

One of these things is not like the other ...

Overthrow the Speculators

The caterpillar that uses tobacco ‘smoke’ to ward off predators

Younger military veterans are angered by budget cuts to their pension benefits

Drone Testing Sites Announced In Six States

I worked on the US drone program. The public should know what really goes on

NSA seizes full control of targeted iPhones via DROPOUTJEEP malware

Why you should never, never, never, NEVER order a computer online

Mozambique's small farmers fear Brazilian-style agriculture

China's growth and manufacturing output decline as property prices soar

Profits May Rise, Profits May Fall, the Capitalist System Doesn’t Care at All

Could the Canaries soon get a new island?

Is Fukushima Decimating Wildlife in the Western Portion of North America?

California could experience 'historic' drought in 2014

Buenos Aires residents protest over 'heatwave power cuts'

'Military-Style' Raid On California Power Station Spooks US

Residents evacuated from North Dakota town after oil train crash

Israel's Gas Ambitions Put National Security at Risk

Oligarchs, Demagogues and Mass Revolts . . . Against Democracy

What does a dolphin use to get high?

Germans Bury Inflation Angst as Merkel Offers New Agenda

Greek Economic Crisis Leads to Air Pollution Crisis

Researchers find 7,300-mile ring of mercury around tar sands in Canada

Special Report: Japan's homeless recruited for murky Fukushima clean-up

Army’s ‘Pacific Pathways’ initiative sets up turf battle with Marines

We’re The Good Guys

The Welfare Queen

What I learned about freedom from hitchhiking around America

Catholic church 'angelologist' declares 'Angels exist but they don't have wings'

Academics Who Defend Wall St. Reap Reward

Why Do People Hate Optimists?

NSA's TAO and "getting the ungettable"

After NSA Whitewash Story 60 Minutes’ John Miller To Join NYPD

The Man of the Year

Ugandans fear curse of oil wealth as it threatens to blight 'pearl of Africa'

All in play in the New Great Game

US Planned Syrian Civilian Catastrophe Since 2007: Timeline

The future of cooking? PRINT your dinner!

The food co-op where shoppers are happy to work

Disposable World

Activists wish Illinois governor a 'Merry Frackmess'

Residents form 'vigilante groups' after cuts to sheriff department's budget

1.3 million losing unemployment benefits Saturday

Jamie Dimon's "Opulent" Christmas Card

More than 150 years after brutal slaughter, a small tribe returns home

Dawn of the remote-controlled SHIP

The Surreal, Cyborg Future of Telemarketing

Thai crisis deepens as army chief hints at intervention

It's such a burden being filthy rich

Alberta transitions environmental regulation to industry-backed group

Republicans in Congress got the testimony they wanted to keep playing climate Russian roulette

House GOP Screw Poor And Meek, Now Want Laws To Protect Christmas Symbols

Bill O’Reilly’s War on Jesus

The Ostrich Syndrone S'plained

Child Sex Abuse Crisis of the Religious Right Grows

What’s the matter with North Dakota?

The U.S. Is A Gas-Guzzling Horror Show, In 1 Chart

Half of Britain to be offered for shale gas drilling as fracking areas face 50 trucks passing each day

Scientists find evidence that BP oil spill killed dolphins in the Gulf of Mexico

'Brutal Power Politics': Merkel's Banking Union Policy Under Fire

How far would Bank of America go to SCREW distressed homeowners?

Accidental Tax Break Saves Wealthiest Americans $100 Billion

It’s Us or Them

Reptiles could inherit the Earth

The 6,000-Page Report on CIA Torture Has Now Been Suppressed for 1 Year

Center For American Progress Discloses Corporate Donors After Investigations

Inside the Saudi 9/11 coverup

Democracy Is A Cesspool In Iraq And Everywhere Else

Tree Find Confirms Italian Alpine Melt

The Black Gold Brigade

Landfill sites are overflowing with GADGETS

Has a natural world wonder just been approved for destruction by the Australian government?

Study says another greenhouse gas is far more dangerous than CO2


Japan lacks decommissioning experts for Fukushima

FBI Admits Activating Webcams To Spy on People (Without Triggering the Indicator Light)

US Government Pays Contractors Twice as Much as Civil Servants for the Same Work

Socialism: Converting Hysterical Misery into Ordinary Unhappiness for a Hundred Years

McDonald's offers its low-wage workers advice on...

Entire New 13-Story Building Tips Over in Shanghai

Mexico Housing Hits U.S. Investors as Plan Collapses

LA sues Citi, Wells Fargo over discriminatory mortgage lending

What the Hell Just Happened in Córdoba?

Syria conflict: Foreign jihadists 'use Turkey safe houses'

Mother Agnes Mariam - Americans Misled by False Mainstream Media Reports on Syria

Seeking copper, Canada's PolyMet offers Minnesota jobs and water pollution

Protesters fell Lenin statue, tell Ukraine's president 'you're next'

Does Lowering Corporate Tax Rates Create Jobs?

Would You Rather Be Born Smart or Rich?

Choking smog over eastern provinces spreads into Beijing

Climate Summit Trap: Capitalism's March toward Global Collapse

Can we avoid an antibiotic apocalypse?

FBI’s search for ‘Mo,’ suspect in bomb threats, highlights use of malware for surveillance

U.S. Military Changes Drone Rules to Make Targeting of Civilians Easier

'Nothing Is Beyond Our Reach'

Nuke troubles run deep; key officers "burned out"

Challenge for the Government: 4 Million Are Displaced, and Hunger Grows

Make the rich change their ways to avoid a 2C rise, says top scientist

David Cameron has turned cowardly yellow with 'green crap' comments

Meet the Spies Doing the NSA's Dirty Work

Arctic oil spill is certain if drilling goes ahead, says top scientist

Villagers brand Prince Charles a bully for sending them letters invoking ancient right to mine under their homes

Pure manure: City uproots FL couple’s 17-year-old garden

Fed Minutes Reveal a Dangerous Power Grab by New York Fed

America And Turkey Are Killing Anti-Al Qaeda Activists In Yemen And Syria

China establishes 'air-defence zone' over East China Sea

Toxic Lakes From Tar-Sand Projects Planned for Alberta

An Orgy of Thieves

Huge area around Fukushima to be waste disposal site

'Cinderella' gas a threat to climate and ozone layer

China's villages vanish amid rush for the cities

Learning to Live in the Anthropocene

US Court Denies Halt on Pipeline Set to Replace Keystone XL Northern Half

Useful Links
Daily Doom Photo

Dilapidated-House-In-Indiana